top of page

What the latest benchmarking means for your digital fundraising

Writer: Jeremy Bennett
Jeremy Bennett
Nov 5
5 min read

Updated: Nov 5

Here at Bigfoot, we always look forward to the release of the latest Benchmarking Project report.


Not just because we're data-driven, but because it gives us a chance to step back from the day to day and reflect on what's happening across our sector.


This year's report continues to highlight the most important thing in fundraising. Retention.


The charities achieving the strongest long-term growth aren't simply focused on acquiring more supporters.


  • They're building stronger supporter portfolios.


  • They're retaining supporters for longer.


  • They’re focused and invested in building multi-channel supporter journeys and engagement strategies that increase lifetime value over many years.


Creating pathways into Regular Giving, Mid Value, Major Giving and Gifts in Wills.


For us at Bigfoot, that's exactly why we're so focused on using digital not just as an acquisition channel, but as a way to support every stage of the supporter journey—from acquisition and onboarding through to stewardship, retention and helping supporters deepen their relationship with your organisation.


Lifetime value is becoming the new fundraising KPI


Just as with last year's Benchmarking Project, this year's report continues to show that retained supporters generate substantially more value than newly acquired donors.


In Single Giving, retained donors generate nearly twice as much income each year as newly acquired donors, while supporters who have been giving for more than ten years now contribute almost half of all Individual Giving income.


The message is clear.

Long-term retention is critical.


For charities, this means investing just as much in what happens after the first gift as acquiring the next supporter.


Because, acquisition is still very important, but only if supporters stay

Digital is now one of the largest sources of new supporters, yet second gift rates and long-term retention remain significant opportunities for improvement. The report highlights a benchmark second gift rate of just 23% for Single Giving, reinforcing just how many supporters are still making only one gift.



It's why, at Bigfoot, we're helping charities invest in digital strategies that do more than acquire new supporters. From onboarding and stewardship journeys through to Always On engagement and automation, our focus is on helping charities improve retention, encourage repeat giving and ultimately increase lifetime value.


The strongest digital programs don't end with that first donation. They continue with thoughtful onboarding, stewardship and connected supporter journeys that encourage deeper engagement—not just a second or third gift, but a lasting relationship with your charity.


It's no longer enough to generate leads or donations.


The real opportunity lies in turning first-time supporters into lifelong supporters.



Building strong stewardship that leads to life-time giving


Another important trend highlighted in this year's Benchmarking Project is that fundraising growth is increasingly being driven by donor value rather than donor volume.


High Value gifts (over $1,000) now account for 64% of Single Giving income, despite representing a much smaller proportion of donors.



Once again, the message is clear. Growth isn't simply coming from finding more supporters. It's coming from helping existing supporters deepen their relationship with your organisation.

Campaigns remain incredibly important. They bring new people into your organisation, create moments of urgency and generate awareness.


But success depends on what happens next.


  • How effectively supporters are welcomed.

  • How quickly they make a second gift.

  • How well they're retained.

  • Whether they move into Regular Giving.

  • Whether they become Mid Value or Major donors.

  • Whether they eventually choose to leave a Gift in their Will.


Rather than treating these as separate fundraising programs, charities have an opportunity to build connected pathways that help supporters deepen their relationship over time.


This is where digital can have one of its greatest impacts. Through connected supporter journeys, automation and personalised communications, organisations can guide supporters naturally from one stage of their relationship to the next, creating stronger supporter portfolios and greater lifetime value.



Grow your Gift in Wills program!


Gift in Will program - Mission Australia by Bigfoot
Gift in Will program - Mission Australia by Bigfoot

One of the clearest opportunities highlighted in this year's Benchmarking Project is the continued strength of Gifts in Wills.


Bequest income has grown by more than 50% over the past five years, making it one of the fastest-growing fundraising income streams. Combined with the significant intergenerational wealth transfer expected across Australia and New Zealand over the coming decades, Gifts in Wills represent one of the greatest long-term opportunities for charities.


But perhaps the most interesting insight from this year's report is when supporters are making these decisions. Almost half of confirmed Gifts in Wills are pledged before a supporter has made a financial gift or within their first five years of supporting an organisation. In other words, charities waiting until supporters have been giving for many years before introducing Gifts in Wills are potentially missing almost half of their future legacy pipeline.


For charities, this means Gifts in Wills shouldn't sit in isolation. They should be woven naturally throughout the supporter experience, alongside Individual Giving, Regular Giving, Mid Value and Major Giving.


This is exactly where digital can make a real difference. Through awareness campaigns, educational content, targeted lead generation, stewardship and automated journeys, charities can introduce Gifts in Wills naturally throughout the supporter lifecycle. Rather than relying on a single legacy campaign, digital creates more opportunities to build trust over time, helping supporters begin considering a legacy gift long before they're ready to make one.


Contactability is becoming a growing challenge


Another important trend highlighted in this year's Benchmarking Project is the growing challenge of contactability.


As supporter behaviour changes, it's becoming harder for charities to stay connected.


Holding a single email address is no longer enough. Organisations need to think more strategically about how they collect, maintain and use supporter data.


For digital, this reinforces the importance of creating opportunities for supporters to share multiple contact methods, update their details and choose how they want to hear from you.


It's equally important to give supporters a reason to stay connected. Through relevant, engaging content, ad campaigns and digital journeys, you can remain top of mind, strengthen relationships and encourage supporters to continue engaging with their cause. The more ways you can stay connected and the more value you provide to your supporter,  the stronger your supporter relationships become. What this all means for charities


The Benchmarking Project isn't suggesting acquisition is becoming less important.

Far from it.

Charities still need to bring new supporters into their organisation.


But increasingly, success will depend on what happens after that first interaction.

How quickly supporters deepen their relationship.


How effectively you can build trust and spark that ongoing friendship.

How intentionally you create opportunities for supporters to move through the fundraising pyramid over time.


At Bigfoot, that's exactly where we see digital creating its greatest value.


Not simply generating more clicks, leads or donations.


But helping charities build healthier supporter portfolios through connected acquisition, stewardship, automation and supporter journeys.


Whether it's Always On fundraising, onboarding journeys, Regular Giving, Gifts in Wills or Mid Value development, digital has the ability to connect these programs into one cohesive supporter experience.


Because the future of fundraising isn't about running more campaigns.


It's about building stronger relationships.



 
 
Bigfoot fundraising.png

E: jeremy@bigfootfundraising.com.au

P: +61 410 371 321

Connect with us on LinkedIn:

  • linkedin-logo
fia-mb-organisationalcc-cmyk-768x342.jpg

Bigfoot Fundraising acknowledges the Traditional owners of the land as the first people of this country and pay our respects to their Elders past and present.  © 2023 Bigfoot Fundraising Pty Ltd. ABN 52654813368. ACN 654813368

bottom of page